A look back at Tuesday
- February
- 25
I have a few random thoughts before diving into last night’s three semifinals. Take a seat. It’s gonna be a long post:
1. Three-person crews create tighter games. Beware to the stars the next three days, especially those who toil in the post. The advent of three-person officiating crews may lend to games being called closer. It already appears to have done just that. Take last night. Here are the players who were in quick foul trouble: North Salem’s Danielle Fiacco, Vicki Riefenhauser and Katherine Caley; Haldane’s Avery Zuvic; Valhalla’s Tamara Tribble and Dana Nucaro; Briarcliff’s Katie Weiner; and Nanuet’s K.C. Jentzen and Amy Delva. That’s nine of the 30 starters who played yesterday, and those are the nine I remember off the top of my head. I’m not saying the zebras were wrong; I’m just saying players may want to be careful. The foul woes definitely hurt Valhalla and North Salem in particular.
2. Crowds were good, but not great. I’m very interested in the crowds this week because Championship Week is kind of on probation. The all-girls day on Tuesday had decent crowds, with Briarcliff and Haldane bringing sizable and vocal student sections. Nanuet and North Salem, which typically bring large contingents, didn’t quite have the support I expected to see. North Salem students may’ve been hurt by the 4:15 start. I also suspect more Nanuet fans will turn out for Saturday’s final. As for the other B semi, expect big crowds for Dobbs and Irvington. Both schools will let students out early (about 40-45 minutes from what I’ve heard) and that should help fill the stands.
3. To Lourdes and Lakeland: Beware! Two No. 1 seeds fell yesterday and one No. 1 in the boys fell Monday. That’s 0-3 for the top seeds so far. Ouch.
OK, now let’s look back at last night…
Hamilton 44, North Salem 32. It wasn’t the fast-paced game I thought Hamilton needed to play but the result was the same nonetheless. The Raiders were still able to find baskets easier than North Salem, which at one point had one field goal over a 15-minute stretch. The Tigers problem was protecting the ball, but it was also even simpler:They just didn’t make baskets.
Hamilton made enough thanks to Shereen Lightbourne (right), who scored 24 points. She injured her ankle against North Salem 15 days ago and had been hobbled ever since. Rehab and rest helped, but Lightbourne still isn’t quite herself. She sat with coach Benji Carter and her dad, Les, a couple rows in front of me during the Haldane-Valhalla game with her ankle in ice. Lightbourne probably won’t do much between now and Saturday, and Hamilton will need every minute it can get from her. She just has a knack for getting things done. She’s very intelligent and understands how to play.
Hamilton will be good for awhile with Maia Hood (11 rebounds) and Ashanti Kennedy, not to mention a rotation that is deep around the big three. But will it already be the Raiders’ time this Saturday?
As for North Salem, it’s simple: The Tigers lost during the four or five minutes Danielle Fiacco sat on the bench with two fouls in the second quarter. It was a one-point game; by halftime they were down 12. I’m not sure North Salem would’ve won anyway, but, in hindsight, Fiacco’s absence and other foul trouble ended all hope. That stretch was decisive. John Lauro told my colleague Mike Dougherty he hoped to get to halftime down six points and have Fiacco fresh for the final two quarters.
Haldane 54, Valhalla 39. If you’re reading the score and wondering what I was thinking picking
Valhalla, you probably didn’t see these teams meet in the regular season. As I said yesterday, the game wasn’t quite as close as the eight-point final margin suggested. I felt Valhalla was better, and I felt it would be better yesterday. Clearly, I was wrong. Haldane proved just how much it progressed. Its strong finish was particularly impressive because if left little unsaid. The Blue Devils were back in the final and left absolutely no doubt.
Liz Milner (left) took some time to get herself involved, but she made plays in the second half. Avery Zuvic, back after more first half foul trouble, found space inside to make a difference. The DesMarais sisters were aggressive on both sides of the ball. Victoria, who has gotten a lot fewer mentions here than Kristen, played the best I’d ever seen her play. Same for Holly Whiston, who competed hard inside against a strong Valhalla front line of Tamara Tribble and Dana Nucaro. Whiston’s efforts helped get both forwards into foul trouble.
What resulted was a balanced team. Sure, it’s not what we’re used to from Haldane, but its effectiveness is now abundantly clear.
On the other side, last night’s results broke the heart of Valhalla, which thought this year the gold ball was its trophy to win. Perhaps the outcome would’ve been different had Tribble and Nucaro stayed out of foul trouble, but as I said earlier the three-person crews made this a tightly-called game.
Nanuet 59, Briarcliff 38. I wish I had the tape of both coaches from after the game. Both were
super-complimentary to one another. Carlos Fidalgo said Nanuet had to play its best four quarters of the season to beat a great team last night. “And let’s make no mistake,” he said. “They are a great team.” Don Hamlin, as he later noted in the comments section here, didn’t just point toward what was clearly a bad night for his Bears. Hamlin told me he prodded his team during timeouts to keep its composure but Nanuet wouldn’t allow it. “Nanuet made us uncomfortable,” Hamlin said. “They were the more confident team.” No one would argue that.
I was most impressed with how Nanuet kept its poise. There is no doubt in my mind (and in the mind of almost everyone I spoke with afterward) that the Golden Knights had command over the game even before Maggie Blair went down with a left knee injury with 3:51 remaining in the third quarter. The mood just felt different than when Briarcliff came from 15 or 16 down to beat them last month. The game wasn’t a shootout. The Bears weren’t playing at their usual high level. And Nanuet seemed to have all the stamina it needed for the finish. (Thanks, in part, to the return of Nikki Saponaro, who didn’t play last time but started and scored 13 points last night.)
“We just never turned the corner,” Hamlin said.
Blair came back on the first dead ball in the fourth quarter. She gave Briarcliff a momentary emotional lift, but Nanuet, in impressive fashion, never quaked. Fidalgo called timeout and the Golden Knights systematically continued to pull ahead. No one player did it. Lauren Kahn (above, right) and K.C. Jentzen were typically productive. But Saponaro hit a few shots and Christine Brezovsky threw a few sick passes. Everyone chipped in.
“That’s a testament to these girls,” Fidalgo said, gesturing toward his team. “They never pressed.”
What we will remember partly from last night was that Briarcliff lost. Nanuet will want its due, and it deserves it, but facts are facts: The Bears last lost a playoff game on Feb. 27, 2007. They had just three losses total since then, and were at one time this season the clear No. 1 team in the section, regardless of class. Injuries plagued them late in the year. Katie Weiner and Taylor Pescetti each had a bum ankle, and Blair’s knee locked up at the worst time. Her dad, Bob, told me she’d never been injured before. “I think I was scared more than anything,” Maggie told me later.
If Nanuet wants to remember last night for more than just knocking off a giant, it will need to win Saturday. Both Irvington and Dobbs will provide tough challenges, but I’m already leaning toward the Golden Knights. Not only did they knock off the queens, they had this within them all season. Perhaps it has surfaced for good.










Josh Thomson has done some of everything since joining The Journal News in March 2003. He began working for the Gannett weeklies during the winter of 2002 as a freelance writer. He joined the daily staff soon after and has since covered various high school and pro sports. Away from sportswriting, Josh lives in Westchester and spends his free time either with his wife, Sarah, or expertly managing his various championship-winning fantasy sports teams. He's visited 21 major-league baseball stadiums and insists that Fenway Park and Wrigley Field are the best by far. Josh graduated from Carmel High School in 1998, then went to Boston University, where, in 2002, he received a degree in communications with a minor in history.








